J.J. McCarthy NFL Draft projection: Scouting report, NFL comparison, and more about Michigan QB

The 2024 NFL Draft features Michigan quarterback J.J. McCarthy, a polarizing figure drawing varied opinions on his potential as a game manager or true playmaker.

McCarthy remains in the Heisman Trophy conversation, showcasing his skills with a completion rate of 75.7%, 2,134 yards, 18 touchdowns, and three interceptions in the current season.

Coach Jim Harbaugh boldly claims McCarthy could become the best quarterback in Michigan's history, emphasizing his exceptional talent.

McCarthy is expected to be a late first-round pick, with a prediction that he won't fall beyond the mid-second round in the 2024 NFL Draft.

In addition to McCarthy, other notable quarterbacks in the draft include Caleb Williams, Michael Penix Jr., Drake Maye, and Bo Nix.

McCarthy's strengths include pro-level arm talent, strong throws into tight windows, well-timed routes, anticipation, solid mechanics, progressions, and high football IQ.

Critics highlight McCarthy's slender build, occasional hesitation and loss of focus under pressure, and inconsistent ball placement despite a strong supporting cast.

Coach Harbaugh compares McCarthy to former NFL quarterback Andrew Luck, noting similarities in passing style. McCarthy adds more athleticism, using his speed and agility to impact defenses.

McCarthy's college season performance statistics showcase his potential impact in the NFL, providing a snapshot of his abilities and style.

As the college season winds down, J.J. McCarthy emerges as a promising prospect for the 2024 NFL Draft, creating anticipation for his future in professional football.

read more about this